Key points
- Autism and borderline personality disorder (BPD) can share features such as intense emotions, difficult relationships and self-harm, which can make them hard to tell apart.
- Research on how often they overlap is limited and mixed. A review found that most studies were small, and could not say how often one is mistaken for the other.
- Autistic women first diagnosed with BPD have described self-harm as a way of coping that started early, and being content to spend time alone rather than fearing abandonment.
- A detailed history from childhood is the best way to tell them apart. Neither diagnosis should be a reason to dismiss the other.
Before you read
This article discusses self-harm. If you are thinking about harming yourself or are in crisis, please contact emergency services or a crisis line now. Our crisis help page lists services by country.
This article is not about which diagnosis is better. Both describe real difficulties, and many people with either deserve better understanding and support than they get. The aim is to explain why the two can be confused, so that people can get the right support.
What BPD is
Borderline personality disorder, sometimes called emotionally unstable personality disorder, is described in clinical manuals as a long-standing pattern of instability in relationships, self-image and emotions, along with marked impulsivity, usually beginning by early adulthood [1]. Features can include intense efforts to avoid real or imagined abandonment, rapidly shifting emotions, chronic feelings of emptiness, intense anger, and recurrent self-harm or suicidal behaviour [1].
BPD carries a lot of stigma. People with this diagnosis deserve the same respect, understanding and care as anyone else, and the difficulties it describes are real.
Why the two can be confused
Both autism and BPD can involve difficulties with emotions and relationships [2][3]. On the surface, several experiences can look similar:
- Intense emotional reactions, including meltdowns that can look like anger or loss of control.
- Difficult or unstable relationships, often linked to misunderstandings.
- A shifting or uncertain sense of identity. For autistic people, years of camouflaging can leave them unsure who they really are.
- Self-harm.
- Feeling different from other people, or empty.
In one study, people with BPD scored higher on a measure of autistic traits than people without either diagnosis, and also showed a strong drive to systemize, similar to autistic people [3]. Autistic participants scored lower than people with BPD on a measure of empathy [3]. The authors suggested there is an overlap between the two conditions [3].
What research says about the overlap
A systematic review looked at all the studies it could find on autism and BPD together [2]. It found that most studies were small and many had a high risk of bias. Pooled across studies, about 4% of autistic people had a BPD diagnosis and about 3% of people with BPD had an autism diagnosis [2]. Findings comparing the features of the two conditions were inconsistent.
Importantly, the review could not tell how often one condition is mistaken for the other [2]. The authors suggested that different underlying differences may lead to similar-looking behaviour, and called for larger, better studies [2].
So the honest answer is that we don't know how common misdiagnosis is. What we do know is that some people are diagnosed with one and later with the other, and that their accounts can help clinicians ask better questions.
What autistic women first diagnosed with BPD have said
A small study interviewed eight women who had first been diagnosed with BPD and later with autism, all with a history of self-harm and psychiatric hospital admissions [4]. They described a long journey through diagnoses and treatments before autism was recognised. Two things stood out that may help clinicians tell the conditions apart [4]:
- Self-harm as a developed, systematic way of coping, often starting early in childhood.
- Being alone was not the same as being abandoned. Several women described little fear of abandonment and real contentment with time alone, which is quite different from the intense fear of abandonment described in BPD.
The authors concluded that misdiagnosis can lead to treatments that don't fit, and that a detailed history of development from childhood is the best way to see the differences [4]. Because the study was small, its findings point to useful questions rather than firm rules.
More broadly, researchers have recommended that clinicians assessing adults actively consider whether an earlier diagnosis might have missed autism, especially in women [5].
Questions that may help
These are not a test, and only a professional can assess what fits. They may help you think about your own experience:
- Were differences in social communication, routines, interests or the senses there from early childhood, before any relationship difficulties?
- How do you feel about being alone? Restful and safe, or frightening and empty?
- What usually sets off an emotional crisis: sensory overload, change, social exhaustion, or fear of rejection and abandonment?
- What does self-harm do for you, if it is part of your life? People describe very different reasons, and the reasons matter for support.
- Does your sense of identity feel unstable because it changes with relationships, or because you have spent years copying others to fit in?
When it's both
Some people meet the criteria for both. In that case, support may need to address both: understanding autistic needs such as sensory load, routine and communication style, alongside therapy for emotional difficulties. It is reasonable to ask whether therapy can be adapted, for example by being more concrete and explicit, allowing for sensory needs, and not treating autistic ways of communicating as something to fix. If you are unsure which description fits you, it is fine to say so. A good clinician can keep both possibilities in mind while they learn more about your history.
An example
Here is a fictional example. Jess was diagnosed with BPD at 22 after several crises and hospital stays. Therapy helped her manage some of the hardest moments, but parts of the diagnosis never felt right. She did not fear being left alone; being alone was where she felt safest. Her crises usually followed overwhelming days at work, not arguments with people close to her.
At 34, after reading about autism in women, Jess talked to her mother, who remembered a child who lined up her toys, covered her ears at birthday parties and had one friend at a time. Jess took these notes to her psychiatrist and asked about an autism assessment. Whatever the result, the conversation helped her describe her needs more clearly.
If you have a BPD diagnosis and wonder about autism
- Write down examples of autistic traits from childhood, not only from adulthood.
- Ask someone who knew you as a child what they remember about how you played, communicated and reacted to noise or change.
- Note which parts of your BPD diagnosis and treatment have fitted well and which have not.
- Ask your clinician whether an autism assessment would be appropriate. It is a reasonable question, not a rejection of the help you have had.
Whatever the outcome, an assessment should help explain your experiences, not dismiss them.
Common questions
Is BPD just misdiagnosed autism? No. BPD is a separate diagnosis that describes real difficulties for many people. Some autistic people are given a BPD diagnosis first, but research has not shown how often this happens [2].
Can a person have both? Yes. Some studies include people diagnosed with both [2][3].
Why are women affected more? Autism has often been missed in women, partly because of camouflaging and stereotypes [5]. BPD is also diagnosed more often in women than in men in clinical settings [1]. Together, this may mean that some autistic women receive a BPD diagnosis before autism is considered.
Should I stop my current treatment if I think I might be autistic? Please don't stop treatment or medication on your own. Talk to the professional who is supporting you about your questions. Exploring autism can happen alongside the help you already have.
AutismTestQuiz's Trait Profile asks about social communication, routines, interests and sensory experience, and whether each was true in childhood. It cannot assess BPD, but your report may help you describe the developmental history a clinician needs.
Take the related test
Trait Profile
59 questions about social communication, routines, interests and sensory experience, and when each one began.
Start questionnaireCAT-Q
A published questionnaire about the effort you put into navigating social situations.
Start questionnaireRelated reading
References
- American Psychiatric Association (2022). Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (5th ed., text rev.; DSM-5-TR).
- May, T., Pilkington, P. D., Younan, R., & Williams, K. (2021). Overlap of autism spectrum disorder and borderline personality disorder: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Autism Research, 14(12), 2688–2710.
- Dudas, R. B., Lovejoy, C., Cassidy, S., Allison, C., Smith, P., & Baron-Cohen, S. (2017). The overlap between autistic spectrum conditions and borderline personality disorder. PLoS ONE, 12(9), e0184447.
- Powell, T., Parker, J., Kitson, H., & Rogalewski, M. (2024). "It was like the final piece in the puzzle for me": A qualitative study on the experiences of autistic women initially diagnosed with borderline personality disorder. Autism in Adulthood, 6(4), 428–437.
- Lai, M.-C., & Baron-Cohen, S. (2015). Identifying the lost generation of adults with autism spectrum conditions. The Lancet Psychiatry, 2(11), 1013–1027.